Learning the value of the $
The $ is the most powerful currency in the World. Compared to the measly INR, it is a mark of the economic prowess of the United States. Albeit, the Euro is gaining ground, but the $ still remains the dollar. Living in a country where the currency is at such a stark contrast with the dollar makes it quite hard when it comes to interacting with people who use the dollar, or its equivalent[1] regularly. The problem becomes even more pronounced when it comes to the internet.
1 USD exchanges at about 45 INR. Quite staggering difference, I confess. And with this difference comes difference in other spheres of life. For example, a bottle of Coca-cola costs much lesser if you buy in INR than in USD. However, buying in INR feels costly when you’re an Indian.
This is another reason why countries like India have such “cheap” labor[2]. In India, a single person can make through a month on about Rs. 25000 easily. That’s less than $600! However, for an American, the cost of living per month is about $3000. That’s almost 150 thousand INR. You can clearly see the contrast in living costs. Hence, when an Indian quotes prices for a job offshore, he’ll take into consideration _his_ living expenses, and not that of the person his employers are ready to pay. That, however, gives out the misconception that Indians are cheap. Yes, we may have a cheaper lifestyle than Americans or most Europeans, but we’re not “cheap”, if you know what I mean[3].
This is probably the sole reason why outsourcing is flourishing. If all countries in the World were to merge together under a single currency, outsourcing would evaporate faster than I finish writing this sentence!
It is also very difficult to buy goods (mostly electronics) which are mostly new and have been released in developed countries. Companies usually “don’t see a good enough market” in developing countries, and we get stuff which are late by years. By the time I’ll be able to get my hands on an XBox 360 (legally, that is), Sony will be ready to launch PS 3 (Yes, the XBox 360 is yet to launch in India.)!
Another thing to consider is the price of such goods. As they are mostly imported by third party distributors, they retain their USD prices, and add in a profit margin, thus putting in grossly out of the hand of most average people.
Let’s go back to the monthly thingy again, shall we? For a $4000/month earning American, buying a $1399 MacBook is a good choice, and one that can be done without much saving and thinking. However, for INR 25000 earning guy from India, buying a MacBook worth INR 70000 involves planning, careful consideration, and months of prior savings.
Coming to myself, I find it really really tough to cope with this situation. And I face it more often than many others as I interact with people all over the World over the internet. When I charge for web design, I am always at two minds over what to charge, and almost always ask a friend. On one side, my mind tells me that I’ll be content with an INR value that I know is much smaller than what many people ask. At the other side, I also wonder whether I’m cheating myself by asking a price that’s much lesser than what is expected off it.
I’ve been approached a few times by people who are interested by the fact that I’m Indian. So, when I ask a price in USD, most of them are surprised. I’ve even had people say, “But aren’t you Indians supposed to be cheap?” I’m highly offended by these remarks, and never entertain such people.
I know I haven’t been able to charge as high as many designers do, but slowly and surely, I’m getting there. As for those of you who say that I’m not worthy of charging such high prices, I say, screw you.
It’s a long and hard road to understanding the true value of the $. I don’t know whether charging in $ is the right thing to do for me or not.
I am not at all for outsourcing. I know it’s good for our economy, but it ain’t good for humanity. That’s the sole reason why I’ve decided to charge the same as everyone else in web designing. Because the moment you start providing goods at a rate that’s 80% cheaper than the original, people will flock to you, and view you in a different light. You’ll also lose respect of colleagues in the same field. I’ve decided to earn that respect.
fn1. Equivalent here is the Euro and Pound, maybe the various other $’s.
fn2. Cheap here can signify 2 things. The first being “Relatively low in cost; inexpensive or comparatively inexpensive”. The second degrading meaning being “Of poor quality; inferior: a cheap toy.” or “Worthy of no respect; vulgar or contemptible: a cheap gangster.”
fn3. again, the cheap in the quotes signifies meaning 2, which many Americans have come to believe.
June 2nd, 2006 at 10:48 am
What you have taken up is a pretty sensitive issue. I had the same problem when I was charging the client. It was always back in my head that people in India charge almost the quarter of the amount I charge them. When I was starting up I used to go to these jobs bidding websites, and every time I wanted to bid on a project I had to compete with almost inconsiderable amount of money, and almost half the estimated time.
I also used to get embarrassed when I come across people complaining about Indian developers charging insignificant amount for the work. I guess it’s up to the client to know that, you won’t get quality for cheap.
June 4th, 2006 at 9:37 pm
Very true. If the client expects people to deliver good work, he/she shouldn’t ask people why they’re asking rates not expected from people of their country.
I’ve faced this problem too, and have almost gone ballistic more than once.
June 16th, 2006 at 10:49 am
very interesting article, I’ve been surpised all the time why Dollar is so popular like English, that is studied by many people in different countries
July 6th, 2006 at 10:32 am
Great Post mate ! Many points you’ve made about are true to many 3rd world geeks. If we could assure that our work and skills are par on (or even better) with the westerns why should we do for a cheap price ?
August 9th, 2006 at 12:21 pm
*Lakshan* : Exactly! We do deserve the price everyone else gets! Oh and by the way, don’t use the term third world country. There should be no such term.
October 4th, 2006 at 4:27 pm
There are so many economical and political calculations that influence these issues, it’s not that simple.